Advertisement
 
Friday, August 01, 2014
Amsterdam, NY ,
Advertisement

Airline deal not taking consumers into account

Friday, August 16, 2013 - Updated: 4:08 AM

The federal Justice Department tossed a misguided wrench into the merger plans of US Airways and American Airlines, arguing that the public's interest is ill-served by a commercial passenger-airline industry dominated by three or four mega-airlines.

Wrong. The public interest is far more poorly served by financially weak airlines artificially hamstrung by government lawyers who think they understand market forces but clearly do not.

The lawyers concluded that the public is better off with two large and healthy "legacy" airlines in Delta and United; one healthy discount airline in Southwest; one limping, bankrupt legacy airline in American; and one midsize contender in US Airways -- as opposed to a market contracted into three large and financially strong legacy carriers (Delta, United and the new, merged American) and discount player Southwest.

Arizona Attorney General Tom Horne joined the Justice lawyers in their suit. Left unchallenged, the merger would reduce competition and raise prices, Horne said.

If this vision constitutes a better market for consumers, it is at best marginally so.

Price and service negatives for consumers can (and often do) result from airline consolidation.

Since 2008, the airline's parent company has lost more than $8 billion. American's enormous debt burden, pension costs and other factors leading to its bankruptcy are not appreciably changed by one or two profitable quarters.

The Justice lawsuit presumes a "government knows better" understanding of the future of the commercial passenger-airline industry. That ignores the rise of aggressive discount carriers such as Allegiant and Spirit airlines, to say nothing of expansion-minded Southwest.

The feds may be waving a "consumer interest" flag, but they are just as capable of acting out of self-interest as the airlines are.

The longer-term consequences appear to include an industry dominated by a pair of stable legacy carriers, as opposed to three, and a handful of also-rans handicapped by a government that presumes to know more about market forces than the market does.

That doesn't strike us as a deal in the best interest of consumers.

-- Arizona Republic

     

Comments made about this article - 0 Total

Comment on this article

Advertisement
The Recorder Newscast

Most Popular

    Lynch ends holdout
    Friday, August 01, 2014

    GASD board looks to fill a school district hall of fame
    Wednesday, July 30, 2014

    Amsterdam the backdrop for movie makers
    Tuesday, July 29, 2014

    Amsterdam 11U reaches state title game; falls to Tri-City Bombers
    Monday, July 28, 2014

    Bad gun law has had some gratifying upshots
    Saturday, July 26, 2014

    Area banquet hall is hitting the auction block
    Wednesday, July 30, 2014

    Teens love taking vacation selfies; adults, not so much
    Thursday, July 31, 2014

    Liberti takes his final ride, gets key to the city
    Saturday, July 26, 2014

    County looking to move operations
    Saturday, July 26, 2014

    At Comic-Con 2014: Hollywood stirs fan fervor to the very end
    Tuesday, July 29, 2014

Advertisement

Copyright © Port Jackson Media, LLC.

Privacy Policies: Recorder

Contact Us